Sunday, October 31, 2010

Vexed: Brief Points on Art, Voyeurism and Pornography by Augustine Zenakos















Panayiotis Lamprou, “Portrait of My British Wife” (via guardian.co.uk)



Vexed: Brief Points on Art, Voyeurism and Pornography                                                  
by Augustine Zenakos

In an article in The Guardian about a photograph by Panayiotis Lamprou, Portrait of My British Wife, on the shortlist of this year’s Taylor Wessing photographic portrait prize, the writer asks what he admits is a “vexed question”: “When does art become voyeurism or, indeed, pornography?”
The first problem with such a question is the precise way it is posed: the concept of pornography is not a direct extension – a kind of ‘bloating’ – of the concept of voyeurism, as is implied by the way the question is formulated. A consumer of pornography is not simply a less inhibited voyeur. In fact, whereas voyeurism may be an extremely ‘open’ concept that easily lends itself to metaphor, pornography is a very ‘closed’ concept that does not lend itself to metaphor at all. (Whereas there is a metaphorically voyeuristic, there is no metaphorically pornographic.) If I were to attempt a definition, I would suggest that pornographic is the kind of image where any narrative is rendered meaningless in favour of explicitness.  (That is why In Thru the Backdoor 2 is pornography, whereas In the Realm of the Senses is not.) Voyeurism does not work in the same way. The voyeur, actual or metaphorical, inscribes him/herself in a narrative, the consumer of pornography is deprived of it.
The second problem with the question is that art and voyeurism are hardly mutually exclusive. More precisely, if we concede that something is voyeuristic, this does not preclude its being art. On the contrary, the element of voyeurism is crucial in countless Venuses and Magdalenes that we admire as great works of art. In the same way, the photograph is quite clear: the fact that this is the photographer’s wife renders our viewing act indeed voyeuristic, but this forms part of the artistic function of the work – it is not its opposite.
The third problem is that whatever is sexually explicit is not necessarily pornographic. The determining factor for pornography is not sexual explicitness – it may rather be approached through the question: what else is an image, apart from sexually explicit, what else does it do apart from revealing all? The reason we cannot consider many works of art as pornographic is that they are complex interweavings of meaning, including narrative strands that incorporate sexual explicitness as their integral part. On the other hand, what makes a pornographic work is its insistence to include only the revelation-by-itself, its eclipse of all narrative, of all other meaning. This is clearly not the case with this photograph.
It seems that a “vexed” question begs a vexed answer: sometimes you can’t get a right answer, unless you have asked the right question.
Post scriptum: Much more interesting than the question of art versus pornography is the question of gender bias in the photograph. Meaning that, although a wife can of course be territorial about a husband, the photograph is dependent on the fact that only a wife can be a true ‘possesion’. This is one of those instances where oppressive speech, though not exactly appropriated as is the case in activist discourse, is given as an a posteriori key to a reading of the work, in order to imply its own oppressive content. This is complicated further by the implication in the designation ‘British’, with all its allusions to northern sexual repression thawed by southern sexuality. (Though not ‘casual’ sexuality, as has been argued; more appropriate would be to say ‘uninhibited’: shaved pubic hair and unshaved armpits hardly spell out casualness.) All in all, this is fighting fire (stereotypes) with fire: a primal fear is contained in the thought of losing one’s women to the PIIGS**. I have to admit I enjoyed it thoroughly.

**PIIGS : An acronym used to refer to the five Eurozone nations, which were considered weaker economically following the financial crisis: Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and Spain. Since the nations use the euro as their currency, they were unable to employ independent monetary policy in order to help battle the economic downturn.

18 comments:

mk said...

Gay Sex Cams


Free Video Sex Chat


Couple Live Webcams


Instant Live Sex Cams


Live Sex Boys Cams


Free Webcam Sex Rooms


HD Gay Porn


Live Dolls TV


XXX Gay Porn Galls


XCamMix.com


Super Movies Gay


Superior HD Sex Cams


Camgirls Online


Free Sex Webcams


Teen Cam Vids


Bed Spy Cams


Cutest Cam Girls


Live sex cams


Teen Webcam Sex


My Hidden Cameras


Free XXX Webcams


Young Virgin Girls


Young Virgin Girls


Hosewife Live


Asian Free Cams


Sexy girl liveshow

Unknown said...

Browse thousands of live cam girls and guys who offer free webcam chat and private cam shows. Cam Girls Live

Surveyor technician salary said...

Freelance Wireless Site Survey guides you implement a wireless local area network (WLAN) improved for your IT and Telecom facilities. Site Survey Specialist provides you a reasonable way to deliver the analysis, performance, capability, Quality of Service (QoS), security, and roaming competency your business requires.

kinglalisah said...

Are you looking for the one of the best and reliable university assignment help australia highest educated writers on any topics assignments? Don’t worry guys, your search is now end. GoAssignmentHelp.com.au always is there for help our customers because we know that our responsibilities. We involve more than 5000 experts specializing in different fields from different subject’s background. Also we pay close attention to the points that will help you fetch more and more marks for our customers. GoAssignmentHelp.com.au is constantly providing the cheapest and affodable Assignment helper, essay help service, homework help service and dissertation & thesis writing service across the world. You can order right now and enjoy the benefits of our exceptional academic papers, Assignment Provider services. If you’re ready to make an informed choice, browse through the reviews we have available.

kinglalisah said...

I have read your website many blogs and each and every content is very informative & helpful for everyone. I admire the valuable information you provide in your release. Thank you for posting it and, I’m really intrigued by what you’ve written. electronics assignment help - english assignment help - android assignment help - fashion assignment help

Kenya online visa application said...

Thank you for this amazing post. Get the 24/7 online visa services with fast tracked Kenya online visa application. The process is simple, fast and very secure

tourist visa India said...

Thanks for sharing this information. Foreign travelers who want a tourist visa India can now apply for a visa online.

Assignment help Ireland said...

online assignment help in Ireland is a service that is provided to students who cannot manage to finish their assignment on time. assignment is usually given with deadlines attached to them. In countries like the Ireland, students often work and study simultaneously which can be stressful and quite difficult for them to manage at the same time. assignment help, however, is the best place for them.

MARTIN KAPOS said...


I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and informative. So, I want to thank you for the effort you put into writing this article. India introduces a new air suvidha self declaration form to help stop the spread of COVID-19. Indian self declaration form registration, You can fill online India self declaration form & read online required documents for self declaration form via India visas website.

Honeywebs said...

best-cracked Android apps site On all Android devices, access to APK files is prohibited by default, but enabling it is very easy. The option is provided in the Developers settings menu for app developers to test their Android apps before formally publishing them on the Google Play Store.We have come to you with a wide range of Best Cracked Android Apps Site List –1.BlackMart Alpha,2.Aptoide – Cracked app site,3.ModAPKDown,4.APKWhale,5.APKPure......

hastenchemical said...

Lime kiln dust Texas is a byproduct of the lime manufacturing process, often used as a cost-effective soil amendment for agricultural purposes and as a stabilizing agent in construction projects.




Charbonnel said...

Discover the finest best chocolate in riyadh, where exquisite craftsmanship and premium ingredients blend to create a taste of pure luxury. Treat yourself to the city's best chocolate, a delightful experience for any connoisseur.




Barber Shop said...

Precision in language matters when discussing complex topics. While you ponder such nuances, consider experiencing the meticulous precision of Facial Services For Men In Mississauga, where attention to detail reigns supreme. Balance your thoughts with a touch of self-care.

global cfs said...

Indeed, the framing of the question can significantly affect the discourse. Much like precision matters in discussions, it's vital in tiling too. Utilizing the right tile accessories ensures a seamless and well-crafted finish.

new evolution inter deco said...

You've raised an interesting point about the formulation of questions and concepts. Just as precision matters in intellectual discourse, fit out contractors Dubai focus on attention to detail to create well-crafted and functional spaces that align with specific requirements.

Anna Thomas said...

You're absolutely right; questions and concepts need to be carefully defined. Similarly, fit out contractors in Dubai pay meticulous attention to detail, ensuring every element of a space is purposefully and artfully designed, with no room for ambiguity.

rekha1989175 said...

In the contemporary era, as concerns about climate change and environmental sustainability continue to gain momentum, the adoption of renewable energy sources has become a key focal point
Visit site :
Solar energy

Assignment helper said...

We Global Assignment Expert help students with their assignments. We have a team of experienced faculty and they will help you with your assignment. We offer case study help, math assignment help, and many more. So if you are a student and looking for budget friendly assignment helper near you. Then visit Global Assignment Help website, we have a variety of offers for you as well. We have a record of delivering results on time with accuracy. Do visit our official website and connect with us.